Pit Bull Aggression Towards Other Dogs

I've been following a recent discussion on a trainer's list regarding whether aggression toward other dogs is a breed trait for pitts that is genetically hard-wired. I have to say I was a bit surprised by many of the viewpoints being shared on the topic. The group discussing the matter is fairly evenly split - some feeling no pit should ever be left alone with another dog and others feeling it's more a matter of the individual dog.

I find it interesting to see how the personal experiences of any individual will define their perspective of this world. While this is natural, I often challenge owners to stop thinking like a human when they work with their dogs. As a trainer, I think it's important to have a broad perspective and understand that no single person or perspective can be all knowing.

Several trainers in the discussion I mentioned worked in environments with fighting lines and shared graphic stories of unpredictable and violently aggressive dogs. Other trainers had experience through ownership and had enjoyed well adjusted, loyal, and trustworthy dogs. As a result these trainers developed two varied and opposing views of pit bulls. But is any singular view ever really wise?

IMO every dog is a product of many things. Its experiences during the early imprint stage, living experiences in current and past environments, leadership (or lack of leadership) in its current environment, and yes - heredity. Certainly breeding is done to genetically select certain traits, and for some breeds this unfortunately can mean lines that are developed to be aggressive fighters.

In the real world there are good and bad dogs, and although heredity can certainly play a role, it's not the only factor making up a dog's observed disposition. Nobody can say how much of a role heredity plays, and for each dog it likely varies. So as I've always advocated - each dog needs to be taken and evaluated as an individual.

To those working to manipulate traits through breeding, you have a huge responsibility. Dogs have co-existed for thousands of years with mankind, and it has been a very special relationship. Breeding that develops dangerous or aggressive dogs betrays this relationship and nature's intent. Good breeding should seek well adjusted and behaviorally sound dogs that can live well with man in this world we share.